Ideas for Thanksgiving Dinners and Pies | Explore Warren


Ideas for Thanksgiving Dinners and Pies

Thanksgiving is a day to relax with family and friends as we gratefully reflect on what we have. You can do that relaxing without having to cook! Here are some ideas on where to go for dinner, getting your dinner catered, and where to pick up delicious pies in Warren County, NJ. Reservations are required for most of the dining spots. Click on the links provided for more information.

Dining Out or Catered In

Apple Mountain Golf Course, Belvidere (White Township): A family Thanksgiving buffet with turkey and other main dishes and sides. Click here for more details.

AMC Mohican Outdoor Center, Blairstown (Hardwick Township): Thanksgiving dinner in the Delaware Water Gap! Multiple seating times and a scrumptious menu. Call 908-362-5670 to learn more or to make a reservation. $20/member; $24/non-member. Click here for more details.

The Architects Golf Club, Lopatcong: Join them on Thanksgiving Day for their annual Thanksgiving dinner.  If you don’t want to cook but want to be home for Thanksgiving, check out their catering options, too. Click here for more details.

Bea McNally's Irish Pub & Eatery, Hackettstown: Offering a fixed price, four-course Thanksgiving dinner, featuring turkey or ham and all the trimmings. Click here for more details.

Buck Hill Brewery, Blairstown: Don't want to cook on Thanksgiving? Come to Buck Hill for a delicious meal, $45 per person and $25 for those 12 and under. Price includes one glass of wine or a pint of beer. Take-out is available as well. Click here for more details.

The Inn at Millrace Pond, Hope: Enjoy Thanksgiving Day buffet with an array of delicious food. For more details, please click here.

Marianna's Restaurant & Banquet Center, Phillipsburg: Join them for their Thanksgiving Family Buffet, or order one of their three catering packages.


Catering and Baking

In addition to the above restaurants, some of which offer catered dinners, here are other places where you can order pies, turkeys, or even the entire Thanksgiving dinner to enjoy at your home without the stress of cooking.

Artic Foods, Washington:  Don’t wait until the last minute to order a turkey that is pasture raised, locally, without the use of antibiotics, steroids, or hormones. These heritage breed birds are fresh, never frozen, and you can taste the difference! They are taking orders through Nov. 18, but to ensure you get the size you wish, they ask that you place your order by Nov. 02. Call 908-689-5033 or stop in the store.  All orders require deposit.

Buttercups Bake Shoppe, Stewartsville: Now taking Thanksgiving orders for pies, cupcakes, cookies and cheesecakes. Details are at this link.

Rath’s Deli, Stewartsville: Now taking orders for Complete Thanksgiving Dinners! All for only $179 plus tax which feeds up to 10. All orders must be picked up by Wednesday, Nov. 21. For more details, please click here.

Donaldson Farms, Hackettstown (Mansfield Township): It’s time to order your Thanksgiving pies and turkeys! Let’s talk turkey… you can order online, call the farm market or stop by to place your order. Enjoy all-natural, free-range, locally-raised, fresh (not frozen) turkey from Arctic Foods and a wide range of pies and desserts baked fresh at our farm market. Click here for turkeys and roasts and here for dessert information.

Mackey’s Orchard, Belvidere (White Township): Let Mackey’s make a pie for you. Also, the Pastry Bakery offers pastries, cupcakes, and cookies all made from scratch on premise and using only the best quality ingredients. There are cakes, breads, donuts, and so much more for everyone. More information is available here.

Marshall’s Farm Market, Delaware (Knowlton Township): Come on by the market and choose from a wide variety of homemade pies. Open all year except Christmas Day. Find them at this link.

oKaysions Katering, Alpha: Call today to reserve your Thanksgiving Dinner Package for 10 people for only $85 plus tax. A sure hit to help you take the stress off your plate this holiday season! Orders must be in by Nov. 17. Pick-up Nov. 21 from 11am-8pm. Click here to learn more.

TreeLicious Orchards & Just Made Bakery, Port Murray: Let them help make your holiday season a success by ordering one of their homemade pies! Click here for details.

VooDoo Farms, Hardwick: Reserve your free-range bronze breasted turkey while supplies last. Click here for details.

Do you have a favorite Warren County place that's missing from this list? Let us know with an email to